Key Takeaways 82% confidence
- Kitco's September 11 Weekly Gold Survey found 64% of Wall Street analysts (9 of 14) bullish on gold for the coming week, versus just 14% bearish and 21% neutral.
- Main Street's retail poll showed a much thinner bullish majority -- 53% (115 of 218 votes) -- with 24% bearish and 23% neutral, after gold's third consecutive weekly decline.
- Gold closed the week at $4,349.42 an ounce, down 1.65%, after trading between a weekly low of $4,292.11 and a high of $4,442.98.
- Markets were pricing an almost 90% probability of a Fed rate hike at the September 15-16 meeting, but only 13 of 48 economists in a separate Bloomberg survey actually expected one -- a rare, wide gap between market pricing and professional forecasts.
- StoneX Group's Bob Haberkorn was the survey's most bullish voice, projecting gold could reach $5,000 an ounce if the Fed holds rates, with only a "shallow" pullback even if it hikes.
- Barchart.com's Darin Newsom pointed to a technical signal -- December gold futures have not closed below their 45-day moving average since August 4 -- as evidence of underlying strength independent of the Fed's decision.
Kitco's latest gold survey shows Wall Street analysts flipping bullish ahead of the Fed's rate decision, while Main Street's bullish majority narrows to 53% after gold's third straight weekly decline.
Analysis 78% confidence
A sentiment survey is only as useful as the mechanism behind the numbers, and here the mechanism is unusually explicit: nearly every analyst Kitco polled built their call around a single binary event three days away, not around gold's fundamentals in isolation. That is what makes the 90%-versus-13-of-48 gap between market-implied Fed odds and actual economist forecasts the real story underneath the headline percentages. When traders price in a near-certain rate hike but the professional forecasters who study the data most closely mostly disagree, one side is going to be wrong on September 16 -- and gold's next move depends heavily on which one.
The analysts who called for higher prices split into two camps on why. Marc Chandler of Bannockburn Global Forex argued the Fed's failure to hike -- the outcome most economists actually expect -- could itself spark a rally toward the $4,460-$4,510 area, since a hold would mean traders unwinding bets they had already placed on tighter policy. Rich Checkan of Asset Strategies International reasoned along similar lines but added a political angle: he expects Fed Chair Kevin Warsh has room to avoid a hike given how mixed the inflation data actually is, particularly with US midterm elections approaching. Jesse Colombo of the BubbleBubble Report framed it as a "buy the news" setup, where a resolved binary event -- in either direction -- clears the uncertainty currently keeping buyers on the sidelines. Darin Newsom took a different route entirely, arguing gold's technical structure (its December futures contract has not closed below its 45-day moving average since August 4) shows underlying demand strong enough that even a hike might not translate into sustained dollar strength, given competing pressure from continued central-bank gold buying elsewhere in the market.
On the other side, Adam Button of investingLive gave the survey's clearest bearish case: the Fed will hike, in his view, and a hike mechanically raises the opportunity cost of holding an asset that pays no yield, which puts "a downward bias into gold" regardless of how well-supported the metal's longer-term case is. Adrian Day of Adrian Day Asset Management sat closer to the middle, reading gold's ability to hold up at all against higher yields and inflation as "a strong sign of underlying strength" that is quietly building a higher base near $4,300 rather than breaking down.
Main Street's thinner conviction fits this picture rather than contradicting it. Retail sentiment tends to track gold's most recent price action more closely than professional analysts' forward-looking calls do, and this was gold's third straight losing week. A 53% bullish majority that has narrowed from previous weeks is consistent with everyday investors reacting to the trend they can see -- lower closes -- while Wall Street's own bullishness is built on a specific, near-term catalyst that has not happened yet. Both readings can be correct at the same time; they are simply measuring different things.
Why This Matters 68% confidence
Indian gold buyers and MCX traders do not vote in Kitco's poll, but the price they see quoted domestically each morning is downstream of exactly this kind of positioning in New York and London. A Wall Street consensus this lopsidedly bullish heading into a Fed decision means a wider potential swing in either direction once the meeting concludes -- a hold could validate the 64% bullish view and pull international, and eventually domestic, gold prices higher, while a hike could hand the smaller bearish camp a short-term win. The unusually wide gap between what markets have priced and what economists actually expect is itself worth watching, since a surprise on September 16 -- in whichever direction -- tends to produce sharper price moves than an outcome the market already expected.
Price Impact
Both segments of Kitco's survey lean bullish -- 64% of Wall Street analysts and a slimmer 53% of Main Street respondents -- but the size of that lean, and Main Street's thinning conviction after a third losing week, keep confidence moderate. The near-90% market-implied probability of a Fed hike sitting against only 13 of 48 economists actually expecting one means the coming week's outcome is genuinely unsettled rather than a clear continuation of either the bullish or bearish case.
Market Snapshot Computed live
Based on metalscost.com's own tracked India reference price as of 2026-09-16 (current). Volume and open interest aren't tracked by this site and are intentionally left blank rather than estimated.
Technical Analysis Computed live
Price is mixed relative to its 20-period and 50-period moving averages, showing no clear trend alignment.
Breakout probability: Elevated — price is testing the bottom of its recent range.
Fundamental Analysis
Interest Rates 78% confidence
Markets were pricing an almost 90% probability that the Federal Reserve raises rates at its September 15-16 meeting, but a separate Bloomberg survey of 48 economists found only 13 actually expected a hike -- a wide divergence between futures-market pricing and professional economist forecasts that is driving most of the disagreement among Kitco's surveyed gold analysts.
Currency Impact 60% confidence
Barchart.com's Darin Newsom argued a Fed hike would not necessarily strengthen the US dollar as much as usual, citing global selling pressure on the dollar and continued central-bank gold purchases as counterweights even if the Fed does tighten policy.
Country Impact 68% confidence
| Country | Impact | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| United States | High | Both the Wall Street and Main Street segments of Kitco's survey, and the Federal Reserve decision they are positioning around, are entirely US-centric -- the September 15-16 FOMC meeting is the direct catalyst for this week's sentiment split. — A Bloomberg survey found only 13 of 48 US economists expect a rate hike even though futures markets were pricing an almost 90% probability of one, the gap that is dividing Kitco's surveyed analysts. |
Industry Impact 58% confidence
| Industry | Effect | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Investment and Wealth Management | Neutral | A sharply divided professional analyst base heading into a binary Fed decision reflects genuine positioning uncertainty across the fund-management and trading community, rather than a one-sided read that would point clearly bullish or bearish for the industry itself. |
Timeline
2026-09-04: Kitco's prior Weekly Gold Survey finds Wall Street analysts indecisive after a volatile week for gold, while Main Street clings to a bullish majority with the CPI release then in focus.
2026-09-11: Kitco's Weekly Gold Survey finds 64% of Wall Street analysts (9 of 14) bullish on gold, versus a slimmer 53% (115 of 218 votes) among Main Street respondents, after gold closes the week at $4,349.42, down 1.65%.
2026-09-15: The Federal Reserve's two-day policy meeting begins, with futures markets pricing an almost 90% probability of a rate hike against only 13 of 48 Bloomberg-surveyed economists actually expecting one.
2026-09-16: The Fed's rate decision is due -- the single event nearly every analyst in Kitco's survey built their gold price call around.
Market Sentiment
Bullish Factors 68% confidence
- 64% of Wall Street analysts surveyed by Kitco expect gold to rise this week, up from a more indecisive reading the week before.
- Only 13 of 48 economists in a Bloomberg survey actually expect the Fed to hike rates, despite futures markets pricing an almost 90% probability of one -- leaving room for a relief rally if the Fed holds.
- December gold futures have not closed below their 45-day moving average since August 4, a technical signal Barchart.com's Darin Newsom cites as evidence of underlying strength.
- StoneX Group's Bob Haberkorn expects only a "shallow" pullback even if the Fed does hike, arguing much of that outcome is already priced in.
Bearish Factors 65% confidence
- Futures markets were pricing an almost 90% probability of a Fed rate hike, which investingLive's Adam Button says puts "a downward bias" into gold regardless of the longer-term case for the metal.
- Main Street's bullish majority has thinned to a slim 53% after gold's third consecutive weekly decline, showing retail conviction fading even as Wall Street turns more bullish.
- Gold closed the week down 1.65% at $4,349.42, extending a losing streak that has not yet been broken.
Alternative Scenarios 58% confidence
- If the Federal Reserve holds rates steady on September 16, in line with the majority of economists surveyed by Bloomberg, gold could rally as traders unwind rate-hike bets already priced into the market -- the scenario Marc Chandler and Jesse Colombo both point to.
- If the Fed hikes as futures markets currently imply, gold could see an initial downward move, though several analysts expect any such pullback to be shallow given how much of the hike is already priced in.
- If the Fed hikes but pairs it with dovish forward guidance, the market reaction could land somewhere between these two extremes, similar to the pattern already seen earlier this month when a hot inflation print still produced a same-day rebound.
Who Benefits, Who Loses
| Party | Stance | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Traders positioned for a Fed hold or dovish surprise | Bullish | A majority of economists surveyed by Bloomberg, and several of Kitco's surveyed analysts, expect the Fed to hold rates -- an outcome that could spark a relief rally given how heavily a hike is currently priced into futures markets. |
| Retail investors who bought gold expecting a quick continuation of the rally | Bearish | Main Street's bullish majority has narrowed to a slim 53% after three straight weekly declines, and Adam Button's bearish case -- that a Fed hike puts a downward bias into gold -- would extend that losing streak if it plays out. |
Investor Watchlist 62% confidence
Educational items to monitor — not investment advice.
- The Federal Reserve's September 15-16 policy decision and whether it matches the near-90% hike probability priced into futures markets or the more cautious view held by most Bloomberg-surveyed economists.
- Whether December gold futures continue holding above their 45-day moving average, the technical signal Darin Newsom flagged as still intact since August 4.
- Next week's Kitco Weekly Gold Survey, to see whether Wall Street's newly bullish majority holds up once the Fed's decision is known.
- The size of any post-Fed price move, given how wide the current gap is between market-implied odds and economists' actual expectations.
Price Risks 58% confidence
- A confirmed Fed rate hike on September 16 could trigger the downward move Adam Button and other bearish analysts expect, even if several analysts expect that move to be short-lived.
- A surprise outcome in either direction -- given the unusually wide gap between priced-in odds and economist forecasts -- could produce a sharper price swing than a widely anticipated decision typically would.
- Main Street's thinning bullish conviction could turn into net bearishness if gold extends its current losing streak into a fourth week before the Fed even meets.
Historical Comparison
Week of September 4, 2026: Kitco's prior survey found Wall Street analysts indecisive rather than clearly bullish or bearish, with Main Street holding a bullish majority -- a notably less lopsided professional-analyst reading than the 64% bullish share recorded a week later.
Related
United States